By Kim M. Smith & Alissa Brigandi
•
June 19, 2025
Most people are aware of their ability to make an anatomical gift, but may be hesitant to do so due to misconceptions surrounding the topic. For example, did you know that there is actually a big difference between donating organs and donating tissues? Many people believe that if they are registered as an organ donor they will not receive extraordinary medical care, which a non-organ donor would be given. People will also say that they are too old to donate their organs, no one would want them. However, this is not the case. An anatomical gift is a donation, at the time of death, of either a part or a whole body, for the purpose of transplantation, therapy, research, or education. Anatomical gifts are governed by New York’s Public Health Law. The law allows donors to document the anatomical gift with a donor card, driver’s license, or any other written authorization, including a Health Care Proxy (as per New York law). New York is one of three states that have enacted the Uniform Anatomical Gift Act. Many people may not know that there is a difference between donating organs and tissues. The statute’s classification of organs includes the heart, kidneys, pancreas, lungs, liver, and intestines, whereas the statute’s classification of tissues includes the eyes, skin, heart valve, bones, bone marrow, arteries, veins, tendons, and ligaments. Anatomical gifts can be made by any individual of sound mind who is eighteen (18) years or older. Absent an express contrary indication, an anatomical gift of a part is not a refusal to give other body parts. An anatomical gift of a decedent’s body may be made by classes of persons reasonably available, starting with the decedent’s designated health care proxy, a spouse, child, parent and so on. If you are enrolled in the registry through the state DMV, Health Online Insurance Marketplace, Board of Elections Voter Registration Form, or IDNYC Municipal ID card, you authorize the donation of all organs and tissues for the purposes of transplant and research. Anatomical gifts may be made to a hospital, school, procurement organization, eye bank, tissue bank, or an individual designated by the person making the gift. An anatomical gift that does not identify the purpose may only be used for transplantation or therapy, not research or education. Thousands of New Yorkers need an organ transplant, but only around twenty-five (25%) percent of the eligible population in the state are registered to donate their organs, eyes, and/or tissues. Many people are reluctant to register to donate their organs, which brings us to a few misconceptions surrounding anatomical gifting. Attorneys have heard clients express their concern that medical professionals will not provide prudent health care or resuscitative treatment if they are an organ donor. Your choice to be an organ donor does not impact your medical treatment. Doctors, nurses, EMS, medical staff, ERs, and hospitals do not have access to the New York State donation registry. The doctors who take care of you during your life are not the same doctors who handle the donation process. Registration can only be seen or accessed by federally designated organ procurement organizations and state licensed eye and/or tissue banks to check if a person was enrolled in the registry at the time of their death. Clients also tell their attorneys that they believe that they are too old to donate, so no one would want their organs anyways. This is also not true. No one is too old to donate their organs. There is a statutory minimum age to donate organs, but there is no maximum. As a client, you may not understand these laws or you may have a few misconceptions about organ donation. One of our attorneys would be able to educate you and help dispel your misconceptions regarding anatomical gifting. They will explain to you the steps you can take to indicate your desires on a health care proxy, such as registering on the donate life registry, discuss the impact of other medical decisions (such as a DNR or DNI) on your ability to donate, who you would want to choose as a healthcare agent and the discretion that person would (or would not) have to choose to donation. If you are interested in donating your organs or exploring the option further, please feel free to contact our office to schedule an appointment with one of our attorneys to discuss and determine what would be best for your respective situation.
Share On: